Carrie Underwood Brings the House Down with “Alone” 20 Years After Her Iconic Idol Performance

​On April 27, 2025, Carrie Underwood delivered a powerful and emotionally resonant performance of Heart’s “Alone” on American Idol, marking two decades since her original rendition on the show that catapulted her to stardom. This special appearance occurred during Season 23’s Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Night, where Underwood, now serving as a judge alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, revisited the song that had been a turning point in her career. ​

In 2005, as a contestant on Season 4, Underwood’s performance of “Alone” left a lasting impression on both the judges and the audience. Simon Cowell notably predicted her eventual victory, a forecast that came true as she went on to win the season. Reflecting on that moment, Underwood shared, “To get that reaction — on one hand, I think at the time, I thought this is amazing. And then about five seconds later, I thought I have a target on my back now! … The compliment outweighed the fear, because that was just … it was incredible.” ​

Her 2025 performance was met with widespread acclaim, both in the studio and across social media platforms. Fans expressed their admiration and nostalgia, with comments like, “Not to be dramatic, but the OG 2005 performance changed my life,” and “And just like that I am 11 years old again in my family living room calling to vote after this performance.” ​

Underwood herself acknowledged the significance of revisiting “Alone” two decades later, describing it as a “full-circle moment.” She shared on TikTok, “Singing ‘Alone’ again is a full-circle moment,” highlighting the personal and professional growth she has experienced since her initial performance. ​

Beyond this memorable performance, Underwood has continued to make significant contributions to the music industry and philanthropic efforts. During the closing night of her Las Vegas residency, “Reflections,” on April 12, 2025, she reunited with Noel Miller, a Make-A-Wish Foundation recipient she met 17 years prior. Underwood presented a donation of over $235,000 to the foundation, raised through ticket sales from her residency. ​

Underwood’s return to the American Idol stage, both as a judge and performer, underscores her enduring connection to the show that launched her career. Her rendition of “Alone” serves not only as a tribute to her journey but also as an inspiration to current contestants, demonstrating the lasting impact of a single performance.​

For those who missed this iconic moment, the full performance is available on YouTube:

If you want more music and videos from Carrie Underwood, check out her YouTube Channel. Fans can also connected with her on Instagram. Get news, updates, and tour info on their official website.